Puppy Love
performed by Paul Anka

Annie accidentally kills a cantankerous neighbour Emrys (Anthony O'Donnell) and Tom falls for geek werewolf Allison, who has run away from home to seek out Tom after being one of a million viewers to see the video of his transformation online. Cutler, who has been upstaged by a new group of vampires, tricks Tom into killing two of them by convincing him that they are the vampires who are trying to expose werewolves to the public. This effectively allows Cutler to continue with his plans in time for the Old Ones' arrival. Meanwhile, Hal goes on his first date in over half a century with Alex (Kate Bracken), a girl he meets in the cafe, along with Tom and Allison. When Hal is left alone with Alex, he is tempted by the sight of her bare neck after she asks him for a kiss and manages to pull himself away just in time. Allison begins to get a taste for killing after staking her first vampire but Tom is unhappy to see how much it seems to have changed her. They argue, and Allison angrily goes to find and kill Goldie, the leader of the new group and last remaining vampire. Cutler, however, ends up staking Goldie instead after she nearly kills Allison. This leads Tom to reluctantly break up with Allison and send her home after deeming his lifestyle unsuitable for her. Annie manages to help Emrys fulfill his unfinished business on earth (which happens to be scaring his ex-wife and new partner out of their home) but just as Emrys' door begins to close, a young woman appears to Annie who reveals herself to be Eve from the future.