When Joy cons Make-A-Wish to send a celebrity to her trailer, Earl remembers and feels guilty about stealing wishes from a Make-A-Wish child a few years back, so he goes to the house where the boy lived to return the pony he stole. It turns out that the boy is still alive and doesn't want a pony, but wants Earl's help in making his movie, 2 The Max. Earl and Buddy (Seth Green) do a really good job at getting together the cast, including Randy, who turns out to be a really good actor. After several storm-offs because Buddy didn't like the acting, all of the actors quit and leave Earl and Buddy to finish the movie. It turns out that Buddy was only going to get treatments for his cancer. Buddy is able to get the movie premiered and Earl is able to get everyone to attend. Buddy dies before the premiere, but Buddy's mother comes with the movie that he had finished before he died. Earl decides to tell everyone of Buddy's death after the premiere, and can cross "Stole Pony from Make-A-Wish kid" off his list.