Hannah hears someone outside her window, and confesses to her friend, Courtney, that she has a stalker. Courtney offers to help her catch the creeper in the act. While waiting for the stalker to arrive, they play an alcohol-fueled game of truth or dare which leads to the two of them making out on Hannah's bed. The stalker, school photographer Tyler Down, takes a photo of the girls and sends it around to the school. This effectively ends Courtney and Hannah's friendship. In the present day, Clay takes a naked picture of Tyler and sends it around the school as payback, instead of throwing a rock through his window as suggested by Hannah on the tapes.
Tape subject: Tyler Down, for stalking Hannah and spreading her and Courtney's kiss photo around the school.