Deacon and Kelly invite Doug and Carrie to their apartment for game night. Doug and Carrie are on a team together, and it appears that their team is going to lose - until Carrie starts to cheat and they win. No one but Doug realizes that Carrie is cheating, and he is shocked. Once they get back home, he confronts Carrie and she finally confesses to cheating. In order to make up for her cheating, they decide to host game night at their house the following evening. To Doug's dismay, Carrie cheats again. She wants to stop cheating, but needs to find the reason behind her sore loser behavior first.