Doug and Deacon stop in Atlantic City after making a delivery in Philadelphia. Doug, who had plans to see a Broadway show with Carrie, makes up a story about an unexpected delivery so he and Deacon can stay and gamble in Atlantic City.
Meanwhile, Carrie now has to take Arthur to the musical with her, where he causes a scene about the use of "his" armrest.
Back in Atlantic City, Doug loses all of his money, while Deacon hits a jackpot. Doug and Deacon get in a fight, and Doug is eventually caught in his lie to Carrie.