When Carrie wins a a raffle at work, the prize is a month's worth of company seats to Knicks games. Doug and Carrie have a hard time deciding what couple they should invite to join them. Carrie suggests her friend Elly from spinning class, and her husband. Little did she know that Stuart, Elly's husband, is very old and very boring. For the next game, Doug invites a friend and co-worker, Eddie and his girlfriend. Carrie is disappointed to find that Simone, the girlfriend is incredibly whiny and needy. Doug and Carrie manage to split up the two couples so Eddie and Elly can then become their perfect go-to couple.