Arthur accidentally starts a fire in Doug and Carrie's basement, so Carrie faces the fact that she and Doug should consider finding him a retirement home to live in. When Doug starts to clean out the basement by removing Arthur's things, he finds a trunk in which Arthur has stored memorabelia from his past, including mementos from the acting career he gave up when Carrie was born. Doug has second thoughts about sending Arthur away, now that he has seen proof that he can be a selfless, caring father.
Meanwhile, It is Danny and Spence's two year anniversary of living together. Spence reminds Danny that they made a deal that if they were still single and living together after two years, they would switch bedrooms so Spence could have the bigger room. Danny doesn't want to give up the bigger bedroom, so the two have a fight over it and come to an interesting settlement.