1Penny starts having doubts about her engagement to Pete, unsure if they're really right for each other and if she really knows him well enough after four months. Jane and Penny decide the best way to find out is to have a couples games night between them, with Max tagging along and inviting Scotty (Seth Morris) as his teammate. The competitiveness gets out of hand when Penny draws Jane's ire after claiming that she and Pete know each other better after four months than Jane and Brad do after 10 years, with Jane being particularly angry at Brad after they come in last place. The aftermath of the game prompts Penny to make an unexpected decision - she breaks off her engagement with Pete after realizing she doesn't have what Jane and Brad have and can't see herself with him decades from now. Elsewhere, Dave looks for a new psychic to help him choose between taking a job at a restaurant or to stay with his food truck business. Alex tries to show Dave that he only wanted someone to tell him what he already wanted to do, which is stay with the food truck.