Michael is upset when he learns that Toby is back as their HR representative, particularly because he is replacing Holly. He tries to get CFO David Wallace to get rid of Toby, but Wallace refutes Michael's attempt. Michael says he has been unaware of Toby's return, which has been going on for a week as he hasn't gone back to the annex since Holly was transferred. Michael tries to pretend to be friends with Toby, but he finds himself unable to do so. He then schemes with Dwight to frame Toby for violating company policy.