Having sent Sam and Jesse to the Dominican Republic for the list, Michael and Fi help his brother, anxiously expectant father Nate, and his friends, two brothers who run a garage that has lost a car filled with drugs belonging to a drug kingpin. Since the car was stolen by professionals, Michael brings back an old cover (see: Episode 2.11, "Hot Spot") to find the thief, but discovers that it was the kingpin's right-hand man who arranged the whole deal and took the drugs. Nate and Fi find the car and steal it back to keep him from pinning everything on the brothers, then sneak it in to his own backyard to make sure he gets the blame. Down in the Caribbean, Sam and Jesse have been working out a plan to steal the list, which is moving around the clock, before the auction. Michael and Fi join them to ambush the runner, then they all return to Miami to decide who they will trust to bring everyone on the list to justice.